Scuttlebutt

Scuttlebutt

Dividend Talks: Broadcom tops 13 chip stocks after the selloff, and Nvidia only rates a B

8 calls: why Micron at 4.5x earnings and SanDisk at 3.9x land in the top tier, why Applied Materials lands at the bottom, and why Marvell's model can't be trusted yet

Scuttlebutt's avatar
Scuttlebutt
Nov 15, 2026
∙ Paid

Dividend Talks · Nov 14, 2026 · 35m · 27m saved

Dividend Talks: Broadcom tops 13 chip stocks after the selloff, and Nvidia only rates a B

In less than a week of selling, Nvidia lost roughly $660 billion of market value, and Dividend Talks, the YouTube channel run by an anonymous chartered accountant, rebuilt cash-flow valuations for 13 semiconductor stocks to see which ones the drop had made cheap.

The chip stocks fell together. Dividend Talks ranked them one by one, from avoid to strongest buy, and put Broadcom first and Nvidia in the middle.

"Falling prices, they don't automatically mean cheap shares." — Dividend Talks

Every stock got the same discount rate and the same long-run growth rate, so the ranking compares how much growth each price already assumes rather than which company is best.

The full episode is covered here so you can skip it. 35 minutes of audio, 8 minutes of reading.

Here are the 8 calls that matter.


This Scuttlebutt Summary is available in full to premium subscribers. If you're not one already, please consider subscribing to keep reading.


Key Takeaways

  • Broadcom ranks first for the best balance of quality and valuation, not the largest upside

    • Its DCF value of $516 implies about 52% upside, and even the low case roughly matches today's price

  • Nvidia sits in the upper half of the B tier, a measured buy rather than a top pick

  • The three memory stocks, Micron, SK Hynix and SanDisk, all reach the top S tier, with smaller position sizes because of cycle risk

  • Applied Materials is the only D-tier name, with about 14% downside in the base case

  • Marvell's 28% margin of safety is not trusted until a model reflects its pending all-stock deal

  • A falling price is not the same as a cheap stock, which is why every name gets a reverse DCF

1. Nvidia Lost $660B in a Week

Dividend Talks opened on the week's damage. Broadcom fell about 5% on Friday and AMD almost 9%, while Nvidia, Micron, Marvell and the chip-equipment makers fell together.

Nvidia's one-week loss was unusual by any standard, in Dividend Talks's view

"In less than one week, Nvidia alone has lost roughly 660 billion in market value. That's not a normal move in a normal market." — Dividend Talks

A move that size, across a whole sector, raised the question the rest of the episode tried to answer: which of these stocks are now cheap, and which have only become cheaper.

2. A Tier List Built on DCF

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Scuttlebutt.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 The Golden Age LLC · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.