The Investor's Podcast · Nov 15, 2026 · 1h 7m · 54m saved
With Kyle Grieve, Co-Host of The Intrinsic Value Podcast at The Investor's Podcast Network · Shawn O'Malley, Analyst at The Investor's Podcast Network and co-manager of its Intrinsic Value Portfolio
Reddit grew revenue 53% in the third quarter, beat Wall Street on sales and margins, and still lost roughly 30% of its market value in a day. Kyle Grieve and Shawn O'Malley, co-hosts of The Intrinsic Value Podcast, revisited the stock on The Investor's Podcast to work out why.
Most of the market read the drop as a verdict on the quarter. Kyle and Shawn read it as a verdict on the next one: guidance for slower growth, and a warning that daily users could shrink if Google keeps sending fewer visitors.
"Millions of people have trained themselves to do the same thing when they Google a question — they type it in, and then they add one word to the end: Reddit." — Kyle Grieve
Shawn first pitched Reddit on the show, bought it at the IPO and owns it today. Kyle, who tracks returns on capital and competitive advantages closely, was the more cautious of the two, and by the end they disagreed on what to do next.
The full episode is covered here so you can skip it. 67 minutes of audio, 13 minutes of reading.
Here are the 14 takeaways that matter.
Key Takeaways
Reddit fell about 30% in a day on guidance, not on results, after growing revenue 53%
Google search traffic is the top risk, falling by more than a million visits a week into October
A login wall is Reddit's answer, and both hosts think it is defensive but sensible
Reddit earns a return on invested capital above 100%, with gross margins around 91%
Stock-based pay ran at about 15% of revenue, offset so far by buybacks
Public shareholders have almost no vote: Advance and Steve Huffman control about three-quarters
Shawn now puts fair value below $100 a share and is "a happy buyer," while Kyle would rather wait
1. How Shawn Came to Own Reddit
Shawn's history with the stock goes back to its listing. As a moderator of the show's own subreddit, he got shares at the offering price and sold them for a quick gain.
Shawn O'Malley got an IPO allocation at $34 through his subreddit role
"I actually ended up participating in the IPO, and I was quite familiar with Reddit since I was a moderator of the TIP subreddit, and for doing so I got an allocation at the $34 IPO price." — Shawn O'Malley
He later built a long-term position at about $105 a share, after the stock fell into the range he had valued it at.
"In my original pitch, I valued Reddit at between $120 and $135 a share. And at the time, it was actually trading above that price, but I said I would love to own it if it ever came back down to that price range. And it did." — Shawn O'Malley



