Planet MicroCap · Nov 14, 2026 · 1h 1m · 51m saved
With Kris Tuttle, Founder of IPO Candy and CIO of Blue Caterpillar
By 1988 the knowledge-based-systems business Kris Tuttle helped build at IBM topped a billion dollars, selling AI to American Express, American Airlines and Union Pacific. Kris, founder of IPO Candy and CIO of Blue Caterpillar, told Planet MicroCap that the boom then stalled because most corporate technology chiefs could not describe their own processes.
Most microcap investors talk about conviction as a feeling. Kris has turned his into a 31-criteria scorecard, and he says it has marked down companies he had already fallen for.
"I run the criteria against them and it gives me the objective view, and I'm like, oh boy, that's only a 60 out of 100, but I really thought this company was more like an 80." — Kris Tuttle
Kris spent years on the sell side at S.G. Warburg and SoundView, then founded IPO Candy in 2009 to cover newly public companies that few analysts follow. He has watched the gap between what a company does and what investors understand from both sides of the trade.
The full interview is covered here so you can skip it. 61 minutes of audio, 10 minutes of reading.
Here are the 9 lessons that matter.
Key Takeaways
Never own a biotech stock into a phase 3 readout
His back-test found that shorting every clinical readout would have made money
Management carries about 50% of the weight in Kris's scorecard, revenue growth about 25%, margins the rest
A bad scorecard result usually rules out a one-on-one meeting, unless the theme is strong enough to keep watching
Small-cap chief executives should be held to a large-company standard of execution, not given a pass for being small
Macro did not matter for small caps in the 1990s and now has "overwhelming impact", which Kris ties partly to passive investing
Enterprise AI in the 1980s never scaled because companies could not show a broad return, a history he links to today's AI spending debate
1. IBM's First AI Boom Stalled
Kris started at IBM in the 1980s, building a knowledge-based-systems unit that passed $1 billion in sales by 1988. Its AI ran credit authorization at American Express, yield management at American Airlines and pricing at Union Pacific.
He gave two reasons that wave stalled: a recession around 1989 and 1990, and a deeper problem inside the customers themselves.
Kris Tuttle says enterprise AI stalled because companies did not understand their own processes
"What we discovered from meeting with a lot of CIOs is they had no idea how they did things. You can't automate something that you don't know how you do." — Kris Tuttle
Without a broad, demonstrable return on investment, enterprise AI never grew into the $10 billion to $20 billion business it might have been. Kris called that history directly relevant to today's argument over AI spending, ahead of Anthropic's IPO.



