Scuttlebutt

Scuttlebutt

Zynga founder: your job is to be right, not to be liked

10 lessons: how "proven, better, new" built Zynga's biggest hits, why he hires people with a chip on their shoulder, and what a $1.75 stock taught him

Scuttlebutt's avatar
Scuttlebutt
Oct 02, 2026
∙ Paid

How Leaders Lead with David Novak · Oct 1, 2026 · 1h 9m · 60m saved

With Mark Pincus, founder and former CEO of Zynga

Zynga founder: your job is to be right, not to be liked

Mark Pincus built Zynga into FarmVille, Words With Friends and Zynga Poker on a gut feeling that adults wanted to play games on their phones, and four years later the company had more than a billion users.

Most founders chase the next new idea; Pincus says the instinct is almost always right and the idea built around it is almost always wrong, which is why he now runs every product through a framework he calls "proven, better, new" before he lets anyone build it.

"Your number one job as founder and CEO is to be right, not to be liked, not to even have this investor ever want to back you again." — Mark Pincus

Pincus has started five companies, taken two public, been named one of Fortune's worst CEOs in America, and sold Zynga for close to $14 billion — a number he told the host, on air, should have been bigger.

The full interview is covered here so you can skip it. 1 hour 9 minutes of audio, 9 minutes of reading.

Here are the 10 lessons that matter.


This Scuttlebutt Summary is available in full to premium subscribers. If you're not one already, please consider subscribing to keep reading.


Key Takeaways

  • Adults need permission to play, and games that connect to real life earn it; most games are "empty calories"

  • The Zynga name came from his dog, misspelled on purpose so the trademark would clear

    • He tried for years to buy the correctly-spelled domain and couldn't; a rival company owned it

  • Scaling past 120 to 150 people broke his personality-driven management style and forced him to build real process

  • He hires for a "broken resume": people with a chip on their shoulder who know the answer but have never been listened to

  • Intellectual honesty is his top cultural value: the most junior person in the room wins if they have the right answer

  • At support.com, he overruled his entire staff and every investor on a product pivot, because a founder's job is to be right, not liked

  • His "proven, better, new" framework stops founders from failing for the wrong reasons by isolating what's actually new

  • Being named one of America's five worst CEOs, and watching the stock fall to $1.75, was freeing: nobody was paying attention anymore

  • He fired his own CFO's bid to become COO, then wrote an unusually honest investor letter about it: "I'm going to write the truth"

  • Zynga sold for close to $14 billion, which Pincus still calls underperforming for the opportunity the company had

1. Why He Only Plays Chess

The host opened by noting that the man who built some of the biggest games of the early internet now plays only chess.

Pincus says most video games are "empty calories" because they offer nothing back in real life

"I don't want this to feel like work. I want it to always feel like play." — Mark Pincus

He said chess is different because the skill it builds, reading an opponent, staying competitive, transfers directly to real relationships, including with his own daughter.

"A lot, the majority of video games don't offer you any value in your real life and they're empty calories." — Mark Pincus

2. Tying Games to Real Life

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Scuttlebutt.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 The Golden Age LLC · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture